SMS direct marketing contravenes CPA

January 25, 2012 12:32 pm 0 comments

Share this Article

Author:

Piet Streicher SMS direct marketing contravenes CPAThe Consumer Protection Act (CPA) allows sending unsolicited direct marketing communications (which is commonly seen as spam by many consumers) under certain conditions.

However, if one looks more closely, it turns out that it is simply not possible to comply with these conditions with SMS communications.

Before sending out direct marketing messages to a database of contacts, a company would have to ensure the following in terms of the CPA:

  1. Check if recipients have already opted-out from direct marketing messages from the company sending the messages.
  2. Check if recipients have opted-out by adding their details to the CPA “do not contact registry”.
  3. Provide the mechanism to afford each recipient the opportunity to opt-out at no cost from these direct marketing messages.

While it is possible to comply with one and two, it is not possible to comply with three - except on the Vodacom network, where a reverse billing channel is provided. Normally, sending an SMS using the reply path to the SMS received would cost the consumer between 50c and 80c, depending on the network. If the sender allows opt-out by calling a toll free number, the call will not be toll free if dialled from a mobile, as toll free numbers only apply to landlines. If the sender allows opt-out via email, four out of five mobile users will be unable to use this, as not everyone has an active email address or access to communicate through email.

Until free opt-out becomes possible, it is technically illegal to send both unsolicited direct marketing as well as solicited direct marketing via SMS. It should be noted that the CPA does not distinguish between unsolicited and solicited direct marketing.

There are two possible solutions:

  1. Changing the applicable section of the CPA to ensure the free opt-out requirement only applies to unsolicited direct marketing. This will legitimise solicited (opt-in) direct marketing utilising a standard rate SMS to opt-out. Unsolicited direct marketing via SMS will then remain illegal.
  2. Introduce toll free SMS numbers on all networks, which can be used for opt-out purposes.

With the second option there are two possibilities:

a)      The cost of the opt-out SMS is carried by the wireless application service provider (WASP).

b)      The cost of the opt-out SMS is carried by the network operator.

While option two above will legitimise spam, consumers will be able to punish senders of unwanted messages by simply replying en masse to the sender. It is also likely that anti-spam activists will publish specific toll free SMS numbers widely. With some smartphones it might even be possible to filter out all messages that include the wording “reply STOP”, and if the reply is charged to the WASP, the phone could be set to automatically fire off a stop message.

With the WASP paying for opt-out SMS messages their financial risk is unlimited. Initial experiments with toll free SMS numbers indicated that these are regularly targeted by individual MSISDNs sending up to 2000 messages which are charged to the WASP. Clearly, toll free SMS numbers are fraught with problems from the WASP perspective.

It seems that the easiest solution is for companies to first get consent before they send consumers direct marketing communications via SMS. With mobile it is possible to get the consumer to contact the company with a shortcode callback advertised in a wide variety of advertising media. This could include TV, online, radio, magazine and billboard adverts. Perhaps if the risk of unsolicited direct marketing messages is reduced, consumers will be less reluctant to use their mobiles to contact companies.

By Pieter Streicher, MD of BulkSMS.com

pf button big SMS direct marketing contravenes CPA

Other News

  • Opinion

    Savvy SA schools SMS

    A Cape Town mom is more than a little displeased with her children’s primary school. During the recent heat wave in the Western Cape, the school cancelled athletics practice due to the extreme temperatures. The teachers went home and children, under the age of 13, had to wait alone outside the school in the heat until their parents picked them up at the time the sports practice was meant to end. The school had no way to alert the parents [...]

    Read more →
  • Opinion

    Contain mining costs by adopting cloud services

    Being agile in the face of unpredictable volatility will become even more important as pressure increases on mining companies to continue growing while reducing operating costs. A solution to reducing costs is based in cloud computing, which has become a topic of interest for a variety of industries, specifically in mining where, historically, the preference has been to own and run applications onsite. Cloud computing offers the mining sector the opportunity to consolidate multiple applications by hosting in highly virtualised [...]

    Read more →
  • Internet

    DOC successfully connects Tshwane college

    The Tshwane North College for Further Education and Training (TNC) broadband project, in partnership with the Department of Communications (DOC), has yielded positive results for teachers and students, says the college.   The Public Private Partnership saw the DOC provide internet connectivity to the college and its campuses through service provider, iBurst. Acting Principal at the college, Charles Pule, said that the TNC Broadband Project was formed  out of frustrations experienced by the TNC following its lack of ability to [...]

    Read more →
  • Opinion

    Cleaning up your applications portfolio

    One of the top five biggest business issues that many IT organisations wrestle with is trying to contain the size of the applications portfolio they are asked to manage. Many organisations simply fail to take a hard look at which applications can be retired and, as a result, the cost of the IT infrastructure needed to support all those applications spirals out of control. Here are some tips on how to rationally clean up the applications portfolio. Set an objective [...]

    Read more →
  • Opinion

    Creating a successful contact centre

    The quality of the consumer’s contact centre experience defines a significant portion of overall brand value – far more so now than was the case a few years ago. For most brands the defining contact centre challenge is to move away from a paradigm where customer service is a gritty and unpleasant coal face experience, and towards positive customer interactions that enhance brand value.  Achieving this shift requires a considerable amount of strategic planning and tactical effort. Decision makers embarking [...]

    Read more →
  • Mobile

    133% growth for FNB eWallet

    FNB’s eWallet has seen a 133% jump in growth in December 2011 - processing over  R140 million in money transfer transactions as compared to R60 million in December 2010. “Every festive season since its launch, eWallet has continued to show remarkable growth. Average daily transaction values have also increased to approximately double the figures we saw a year ago,” says Yolande van Wyk, CEO of FNB eWallet Solutions.   eWallet recently announced various enhancements to the eWallet functionality. Customers can [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured Internet

    National libraries get connected

    Vodacom has completed the implementation of Phase 1 of a libraries project for internet connectivity in the North West, Limpopo and Mpumalanga provinces.

    The National Department of Arts and Culture multi-million rand project is managed and driven by the National Library of South Africa (NLSA) and is being implemented through partnerships with service providers and provincial libraries.

    When completed, almost 300 community libraries will be connected using VSAT and Vodacom ADSL services.

    “This project started when we were implementing the SITA/ NLSA open source Library Information Management System (LIMS),” says Lesiba Ledwaba, CIO National Library of South Africa and head of project.

    Read more →
  • Mobile

    Telkom searches for mobile unit MD

     Telkom has embarked on a recruitment process to appoint a MD for its mobile arm as it gears up to offer several new propositions. The MD will join 8ta, which was introduced in October last year and currently has a market share of  nearly 2%, and become an exco member of the Telkom Group. “It is of great importance that we keep the momentum going. In fact, delivery on our mobile investment features very high on the corporate agenda. It is [...]

    Read more →
  • Opinion

    SMS direct marketing contravenes CPA

    The Consumer Protection Act (CPA) allows sending unsolicited direct marketing communications (which is commonly seen as spam by many consumers) under certain conditions. However, if one looks more closely, it turns out that it is simply not possible to comply with these conditions with SMS communications. Before sending out direct marketing messages to a database of contacts, a company would have to ensure the following in terms of the CPA: Check if recipients have already opted-out from direct marketing messages [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured Mobile

    Consumer Commission tackles high roaming fees

    National Consumer commissioner, Mamodupi Mohlala, has revealed that the commission has set its sights on tackling the high cost of international roaming for cellphone users.

    Briefing the National Assembly’s Trade and Industry Portfolio Committee, Mohlala said the commission would seek the advice of experts around international roaming fees.

    The commission says it is currently looking into cellphone and internet service providers that provide pre-paid data but do not allow consumers to carry over unused data to the next month.

    Read more →
Feedback

SA IT NEWS Feedback

We appreciate any and all feedback about our site; praise, ideas, bug reports you name it!

AUGUST / SEPTEMBER ISSUE | Engage in our latest issue of Saitnews Magazine titled Woman in IT Download Now